CO129-229 - Acting Governor Marsh & Public Offices - 1886 [11-12] — Page 283

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

281

therefore inability.

I wrote hurriedly, representing my

I respectfully

submit to Your

Excellency and the Council that so far

I had done no

wrong.

off the Government was not satisfied.

with my

letter of this instant, I submit that

I should then have been called upon for explanation, and if that had been

unsatisfactory it was

open to the Acting

Governor to issue a positive order

for me to do the work, the Government taking

the consequences. If the

Acting Governor, after being acquainted with all the circumstances of

the case, had given

a positive order,

refusal on my part might then have been followed by the present charges. As it is, I have been placed in this position

by my own, and without any wish of mine or any opportunity of avoiding it: His Excellency immediately on receipt of my letter of Saturday 7th charged me

with insubordination and disobedience of orders.

I wish to dwell upon the fact that these charges have been formulated with undue haste, and that if the Government had been more deliberate they

would never have been preferred.

The action of the Government subsequent to the 8th when the charges

were made, I

have not been able to understand, and I

submit that when lying

under these charges the action

of the Government towards me should have been clear and

unmistakable, and I should have been left in no doubt as to what was intended.

From the 8th when charged with disobedience, until the 20th when the decision of the Council

was communicated

I believed, and I had a right to believe, that my explanation would be satisfactory.

At the least, during this period, while the matter was in suspense, and the question "sub judice"

His Excellency informed Dr Ayres that I had been ordered...

Edit History

2026-05-25 07:04:07 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
281 therefore inability. I wrote hurriedly, representing my I respectfully submit to Your Excellency and the Council that so far I had done no wrong. off the Government was not satisfied. with my letter of this instant, I submit that I should then have been called upon for explanation, and if that had been unsatisfactory it was open to the Acting Governor to issue a positive order for me to do the work, the Government taking the consequences. If the Acting Governor, after being acquainted with all the circumstances of the case, had given a positive order, refusal on my part might then have been followed by the present charges. As it is, I have been placed in this position by my own, and without any wish of mine or any opportunity of avoiding it: His Excellency immediately on receipt of my letter of Saturday 7th charged me with insubordination and disobedience of orders. I wish to dwell upon the fact that these charges have been formulated with undue haste, and that if the Government had been more deliberate they would never have been preferred. The action of the Government subsequent to the 8th when the charges were made, I have not been able to understand, and I submit that when lying under these charges the action of the Government towards me should have been clear and unmistakable, and I should have been left in no doubt as to what was intended. From the 8th when charged with disobedience, until the 20th when the decision of the Council was communicated I believed, and I had a right to believe, that my explanation would be satisfactory. At the least, during this period, while the matter was in suspense, and the question "sub judice" His Excellency informed Dr Ayres that I had been ordered...
Baseline (Original)
281 therefore inability. I wrote hurriedly, representing my I respectfully submit to Your Excellency and the Council that sofer I had done wo wrong. off the Government was not satisfied. with my letter off rych instant, I submit that I should then have been called upon for explanation, and if that had been i satisfactory it was open to the Acting Governor to issue a positive order for to do the work, the Government laking the consequences. If wade all responsibility for the reling Governor after being acquainted with all the circumstances of the case, had had given AMCO A positive order, reficval on my part might then have been followed by the present charges. et it is, I nerve ben placed in this position by own, and without no wish of my any opportunity of avoiding it: His Excellency immediatly on receipt of my letter of Serday 7th charging with with insubordination and disobedience oforare. I wish to dwell upon the fact that these charges have been formulated with undue haste, and that if the Government had_._ more deliberate they been preferred. been would rever have. The action of the Government subsequent to the 8th when the charges es were made, I have not been able to understand, and I submit that when lying under each charges the action the action of the Government lowards me should have been clean und eur mistakable, and I should have been left in us doubt as to what was intended. From the 8th when charged with disobedience, until the 20th where the decision of the Council lo que, was communicated I believed, and I had a right to believe, that my explanation would be satisfactory rever the lees, during this period, while the matter was in eusponse, and the question " subjudice " "His Excellency informed Qr Ayres that I had been- order-çã iru
2026-05-25 07:04:07 · Baseline
View content

281

therefore inability.

I wrote hurriedly, representing my

I respectfully

submit to Your

Excellency and the Council that sofer

I had done wo

wrong.

off the Government was not satisfied.

with my

letter off rych instant, I submit that

I should then have been called upon for explanation, and if that had been i

satisfactory it was

open to the Acting

Governor to issue a positive order

for

to do the work, the Government laking

the

consequences. If

wade

all responsibility for the reling Governor after being acquainted with all the circumstances of

the case, had

had given

AMCO A

positive order,

reficval on my part might then have been followed by the present charges. et it is, I nerve ben placed in this position

by

own, and without

no wish of my any opportunity of avoiding it: His Excellency immediatly on receipt of my letter of Serday 7th charging

with

with insubordination and disobedience oforare.

I wish to dwell upon the fact that these charges have been formulated with undue haste, and that if the Government had_._

more deliberate they been preferred.

been

would rever have.

The action of the Government subsequent to the 8th when the charges

es were made, I

have not been able to understand, and I

submit that when lying

under each

charges the action

the action of the Government lowards me should have been clean und

eur mistakable, and I should have been left in us doubt as to what was intended.

From the 8th when charged with disobedience, until the 20th where the decision of the Council

lo que,

was communicated

I believed, and I had a right to believe, that my explanation would be satisfactory

rever the lees, during this period, while the matter was in eusponse, and the question " subjudice " "His Excellency informed Qr Ayres that I had been-

order-çã

iru

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.